Did Thanksgiving save room for cheese?
Issue No. 18 | Curds or no? | Thanksgiving Advice
Last weekend I sat in a cafe on the Upper West Side, drank a cappuccino, and did what any gay, childless, middle-aged man does in his spare time: I thought about cheese. Smiling dumbly into the distance, I daydreamed of the veined goat cheeses, the melty Alpine-styles, that I might soon eat. And I had a barely conscious thought: isn’t it insane that, as obsessed with cheese as America is, we don’t eat it on Thanksgiving?
A few days later two newsletters, written respectively by two respected cooks, hit my inbox only a minute apart. Their subject lines stacked on top of each other; both mentioned mac and cheese. I deleted these before even opening them, but then I reconsidered. I wanted to confirm: They were pitching their macs for Thanksgiving, right? Well, yes and no. “I don’t usually have macaroni and cheese on my Thanksgiving table,” the first one read. “Macaroni and cheese has absolutely no place on the Thanksgiving table,” read the other. And yet both contained mac and cheese recipes.
So which is it, ladies? Are we eating cheese at Thanksgiving or not?